|
| |
The 'Evian
Conference
A conference on refugee problems was held on the
French shore of Lake Geneva at Evian-les-Bains in July 1938. U.S. President
Roosevelt invited European, American,
and Australian delegates to discuss the emigration
and resettlement of those persecuted
because of their race or religion. At the time,
many refugees were fleeing from Germany
and Austria.
Thirty one countries met under the chairmanship
of MyronTaylor, Roosevelt's emissary.
Encyclopedia Judaica, Volume 6
Keter Publishing House, Ltd. 1973
What Happened
at Evian
A
dramatization
| Mr. Taylor: |
|
Good
afternoon and welcome to Evian. My name is Myron C. Taylor. I represent the United
States of America. I am empowered by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, whose idea it
was to convene this conference, to call this meeting to order. We represent, in total, 32 countries of the world. We know what our
purpose is in being here today. The Jews of Germany and Austria must flee Hitler and the
Nazis who are making it impossible for them to live in peace and freedom. They must find a
place of refuge. We can be the Nations of Asylum. We can offer the Jews security.
Let us begin to hear the witnesses .. Jewish men and women
will report on the conditions they are being forced to endure in their own countries
during this difficult time.
|
| First man: |
|
Thank you
for letting us tell our stories. Thank you for convening such a conference. Let us
hope that this is the last time such a conference is necessary.
|
| Second man: |
|
Half of us
have been fired from our jobs .. and unable to find other work. We were fired for
one reason, and for one reason only: We are Jews!
|
| Third man: |
|
We Jews are
doctors, lawyers, teachers and business people. German law does not allow us to be
farmers, so we cannot work for ourselves. Without work, we cannot live.
|
| First woman: |
|
We are
ready and willing to leave our homes in Germany and start anew in any country that will
open its doors to us. We will learn your language; we will work hard and become good
citizens of your countries. But you must help us get started. The German government has
said that if we leave, we must abandon all of our possessions and leave behind all of our
money. They will allow us to take with us no more than ten Reichmarks. In U.S. currency
that is less than $5.00.
|
| Fourth man: |
|
The Germans
have made their feelings about us very plain. Throughout Germany signs are hanging above
hotel entrances, in shop windows, in public parks, on park benches, in theaters and near
swimming pools. The signs say; No Jews allowed.
|
| Second woman: |
|
I took my
little girl to school last week. She is in kindergarten. She asked me what the signs
hanging above the kindergarten entrance said. I didn't tell her. I couldn't tell my little
girl that those signs said Jewish scum.
|
| Fifth man: |
|
In my town,
we cant buy milk for our children or groceries; signs with 'No Jews and dogs allowed' hang
at entrances to the shops, forbidding us to enter. We are not allowed to farm the land, so
we cannot grow our own food. When our children are ill, which they are often these days,
stores that sell medicine are verboten .. forbidden to us because we are Jews.
We are desperate to leave Germany!
|
| Third woman: |
|
A few weeks
after German troops took over Austria, tens of thousands of Austrian Jews were locked up
in concentration camps. My friends, my uncles ... all were taken.
|
| Fourth woman: |
|
The German
soldiers ruling over us look so well-fed, so handsome and comfortable. They wear clean
uniforms and shiny black boots. When they first entered Austria, I almost admired them!
But those same soldiers beat up Jews on the street for no reason at all - except that they
are Jews. They beat men, women, and even children. I've seen it with my own eyes. And the
Austrian people just stand there and watch. They don't utter a word of complaint.
|
| Fifth woman: |
|
I was on my
way to the store when soldiers stopped me. They forced me down on my hands and knees and
pushed a bucket of water in front of me. Here! they ordered. They always order
... they never talk ... they order. Scrub the gutter! I was humiliated, but I
was frightened, so I did what they ordered. People in the street just stood by watching
... Some even laughed; even as I began to cry. Look at my hands. They are burned raw ...
not from the work, but because the Nazis had poured acid into the scrub water.
|
| Sixth man: |
|
We Jews are
only one percent of the whole German population, only three percent the Austrian. And yet
Hitler blames us for everything. Listen to his words: If the Jews of Europe again
make a World War.. the result will be the wiping out of the Jews in Europe! We are
frightened. We are afraid for our future and for our children's future. You must help
us!
|
| Myron Taylor: |
|
This has
been an exhausting week. We have all listened very carefully to the witnesses testimony.
We understand their concern. Now we must be prepared to explain what we can do to help
them. First I want to say that the American government is proud of its fair and liberal
immigration laws. We allow many people from all over the world to enter, and we treat them
well. In order to continue this policy, the United States must maintain a quota system. In
other words, we can only allow a certain number of people into the U.S. from each European
country. This system is for the benefit of United States residents as well as for new
immigrants. I'm sure you can all understand that. "I personally am deeply sorry about what I have heard this
week. But we have limits. We will do what we can to help, but only within our existing
quota system. We can take a total of 27,370 German and Austrian Jews this year. That is
all. I am sorry. There are 31 other nations represented here who can help the one half
million Jews who want to leave Germany and Austria. Let us now hear from the honorable
delegates from these countries.
|
Delegate from
England: |
|
As
England's delegate I wish to explain my government's position: We currently administer the
affairs of the country called Palestine. We have done this since 1917. Some people feel
that the problem would be solved if we would only open the gates of Palestine to all
Jewish immigrants, without restrictions. But I
would like to state clearly and strongly that this will not work. First, Palestine is a
very small country. It could not possibly absorb so many people. Second, there are special
problems with the local population there. We cannot ignore their feelings in this matter.
We cannot open Palestine to unlimited Jewish immigration.
|
Delegate from
France: |
|
Bonjour. My
country, France, continues to be true to our long-standing tradition of welcoming all
people who wish to come and live in our beautiful country. We understand President
Roosevelt's effort to help the Jews, and we applaud this effort. Unfortunately, France has
reached the point of saturation regarding new immigrants. We simply have no more
room.
|
Delegate from
Canada: |
|
I am the
delegate from Canada. As you may know, we are the second largest country in the entire
world. We have a great deal of land, and we would be happy to help. But we must take only
the kinds of people who will make our country grow and prosper. Right now we need farmers
and are prepared to take all Jews who are farmers.
|
Delegate from
Brazil: |
|
I represent
Brazil, the fifth largest country in the world. We could take half a million people, as
every country here could, but our country is Christian and we have a brand new law in
Brazil. That law states that we can only take in Christians. Any Jew who has a certificate
of baptism may enter our country.
|
Delegate from
Australia: |
|
I am happy
to be representing Australia. We are the sixth largest country in the world, and we have
great tracts of empty land and very few people. But you see, our small population is very
homogeneous. Our people all have the same values and the same customs. We have no racial
problems in Australia and we don't want to import one from Europe. We think it would be
best for us not to allow any Jews into our country at this time. I'm sure you
understand.
|
Delegate from
South America: |
|
I represent
South America. Our four countries, would like very much to help, but we have rules that do
not admit people whom we call 'undesirables'. We have to protect our own people. We
consider doctors, lawyers, writers, teachers and business people undesirables.
|
Delegate from
Holland: |
|
I am the
delegate from Holland, one of the smallest nations represented here. Since we do not like
what the Germans are doing to their Jewish citizens, we will allow Jews to enter Holland,
provided that they look for a home elsewhere as soon as possible.
|
Delegate from
Denmark: |
|
I represent
the country of Denmark. We too are a tiny country. But we have always lived in peace with
our Jewish citizens. We will welcome 1,500 Jews who want to immigrate to our
country.
|
Delegate from
Dominian
Republic: |
|
I am the
delegate from the Dominican Republic, which is also one of the smallest nations at this
conference. We need people, and we will take even more than 1,500 Jews. But there is one
condition. To enter, they must agree not to be Jews any longer.
|
| Myron Taylor: |
|
Thank you
all very much. I know you have all done what you could. But now it is time to consider one
more solution. The Jewish refugees will cause a severe economic and social strain on
countries with limited capabilities to absorb them and care for them properly. We do not
want this strain to interfere with international relations, which could have serious
world-wide implications. It seems clear that we should pass the following resolution:
No Jews will be taken in anywhere unless they bring all their
assets with them. No Jews will be taken in anywhere unless they are able to support
themselves. Let us now vote. All in favor of this
resolution?
|
All delegates
together: |
|
Aye! |
| Myron Taylor: |
|
Opposed?
None? Then the resolution is passed. I am sorry. We did what we could. This conference
stands adjourned. |
Questions to think about
1) Put yourself in the position of each government. What
arguments can be used for and against admitting the refugees? What factors should take
precedence in a decision like this? Explain your answer.
2) In a speech Hitler gave on January 30, 1939, he said:
"It is a shameful example to observe today how the
entire democratic world dissolves in tears of pity; but then, in spite of its obvious duty
to help, closed its heart to the poor, tortured Jewish people."
What, in essence, is Hitler saying?
Compare the date of this speech with the date on which the
St. Louis sailed from Hamburg. What conclusion can you draw?
The St. Louis sailed out of Hamburg, Germany, with 937
Jewish passengers aboard. Despite the fact that they held Cuban landing visas, they were
refused entry into Cuba. When the St. Louis approached an American port, two U.S. Coast
Guard ships were called out to prevent it from docking. Denied landing, the ship had to
return its Jewish passengers to Europe. The year was 1939.
769 Jews left Nazi-allied Romania on the Struma
in December 1941 - the very month the Nazis began operating their first death camp in
Poland. The British refused to let the ship proceed to its destination - Haifa, Palestine
- because none of the passengers held valid immigration permits. The Turks also refused to
let the Struma dock, so for ten weeks the ship lay in the waters off Istanbul. On
February 24, 1942, the Turks declared the ship to be a danger to navigation and to public
health. They towed it out to sea, where it sank six miles from the coast. Only one refugee
managed to swim to shore.
| |
|